What Manner of Man

BUY

What Manner of Man by St John Starling

What would tempt you to sin? A sweet and naïve priest at war with his desires, tormented by nightly dreams of a wicked demon. A vampire lord forced to do the unthinkable, battling needs he can scarcely control. Father Ardelian has been summoned to a distant, secluded island to perform an exorcism. What will happen when he begins to suspect his host — the mysterious, nocturnal lord of the manor — of wanting him for another reason entirely? Will the piously celibate priest be able to resist his monstrous host’s diabolically seductive charms? What Manner of Man is a blasphemous queer horror romance about a priest and a vampire, inspired by Bram Stoker’s Dracula. A tale of forbidden love with themes of devil worship, demonic possession, and human sacrifice — this is the long-awaited completed version of the widely beloved story which rose to fame and fortune in the form of a newsletter!

AdultHorror/Paranormal CreaturesRomance/ParanormalHorror/Supernatural and OccultRomance/HistoricalDiversity Representation/LGBTQ+

Content Warning: blasphemy, priest kink, Catholic guilt, self-flagellation, sexual repression, corruption kink, blood-drinking, ceremonial knifeplay, themes of demon possession and exorcism, improper use of church confessional


Get What Manner of Man

Story Website

Goodreads

StoryGraph


Add Review Nominate for Indie Ink Awards 2025

Reviewed by Shrike avatar Shrike on :

Worldbuilding: Aided the story
Plot: Straightforward
Characters: Roles are clear
Storytelling: Descriptive
Immersion: Didn’t want to put the book down
Emotional Response: Strong emotions
Thought Provoking: New ideas came up
Cover: Matches the story well

This queer gothic features a charmingly naive narrator who quickly won my heart. What Manner of Man captures the magic of classic adventure novels. I found it difficult not to devour it in one sitting, eager to learn the fate of Father Ardelian.

Read Full Review


Reviewed by spidercrab avatar spidercrab on :

Worldbuilding: Aided the story
Plot: Straightforward
Characters: Roles are clear
Storytelling: Descriptive
Immersion: Didn’t want to put the book down
Emotional Response: Strong emotions
Thought Provoking: Did some research after reading
Cover: Matches the story well

the only good gay priest romance ever written


Reviewed by inferiorwit avatar inferiorwit writer on :

Worldbuilding: Aided the story
Plot: Straightforward
Characters: Roles are clear
Storytelling: Descriptive
Immersion: Didn’t want to put the book down
Emotional Response: Strong emotions
Thought Provoking: New ideas came up
Cover: Matches the story well

Beautifully written, delightfully blasphemous and breathlessly horny.


Submitted by stjohnstarling avatar stjohnstarling on


© 2025 Hakea Media | Terms | Privacy